Choose a fixed-price contract when you can write down what "done" looks like before any work starts. Choose time and materials when the work will be discovered as it is built. Fixed price moves the cost risk to the software company. Time and materials keeps that risk with you, so it needs a spending ceiling and regular reviews. Most disagreements over budget come from picking the model that does not match how clear the scope really is.
What is the difference between fixed price and time and materials?
In a fixed-price contract you agree one price for a defined scope. The US federal procurement rules, which have spelled this out in more detail than most guides, say a firm-fixed-price contract puts "maximum risk and full responsibility for all costs and resulting profit or loss" on the contractor, and gives it "maximum incentive" to control costs (FAR 16.202-1).
In a time-and-materials contract you pay for the days or hours worked, plus any materials. The same rules allow it "only when it is not possible at the time of placing the contract" to estimate the work accurately, and warn that it "provides no positive profit incentive to the contractor for cost control or labor efficiency" (FAR 16.601). That is why they require the buyer to watch progress closely and to set a ceiling price that the contractor exceeds at its own risk.
| Fixed price | Time and materials | |
|---|---|---|
| Who carries the cost risk | The software company | You |
| What you agree up front | Scope, deliverables, price | Rates, a ceiling, a review rhythm |
| When the scope changes | A change request and a new price | The work continues, and the bill grows |
| What you have to manage | Writing a clear scope | Watching progress and priorities every week |
| Best for | Work you can describe in full today | Work you will understand only by doing it |
When does a fixed-price contract work?
Fixed price works when the risks can be named and priced before the work begins. The federal rules list the conditions: specifications that are "reasonably definite", cost information that "permits realistic estimates", and performance uncertainties that "can be identified" with a reasonable estimate of their cost (FAR 16.202-2).
In software terms, that means you can already list:
- Every screen, report and user role
- Every system the software must connect to, with documentation for each
- The data that has to move from the old system, and its condition
- Who signs off on each part, and how quickly they can do it
A company website with known pages, a first version of an app with agreed user flows, or a connection to a well-documented payment gateway are good fixed-price candidates. Expect the price to include a margin for risk. The vendor is agreeing to absorb surprises, and the rules describe the fixed price as "representing assumption of the risks involved."
When is time and materials the better choice?
Time and materials fits work where the shape of the answer is unknown at the start. Three common cases:
- An AI feature whose accuracy depends on data nobody has examined yet
- Connecting to an older system with little or no documentation
- An early product where you expect to change direction after users try it
Protect yourself the way the federal rules do. Agree a ceiling the vendor cannot pass without your written approval, review the work and the spend on a fixed rhythm, and keep a ranked list of priorities so the most valuable work happens first if the money runs out.
A common middle path is to buy a short discovery phase on time and materials, write the scope from what it finds, and then agree a fixed price for the build.
What about retainers and subscriptions?
Elroot Labs works with four engagement models: fixed-price projects, time and materials, monthly retainers, and product subscriptions. The last two answer different questions.
A monthly retainer covers ongoing work once a system is live: support, small changes, and a team that already knows the code. It suits organisations that need a steady stream of improvements but not a full-time in-house team.
A product subscription is for software that already exists. You pay to use and configure a product instead of commissioning a new one, which usually means a faster start and less custom work.
What actually moves the cost?
Whichever model you choose, four things move the price of the projects we work on more than anything else.
- Integrations. Connecting to ABDM, an existing hospital information system, a payment gateway or a government portal. Each one has its own rules, test environments and approval steps.
- Compliance. Obligations under India's Digital Personal Data Protection Act, where the data must live, and audit requirements all add design and testing work.
- Data migration. Moving years of records out of an old system usually means cleaning them first, and the condition of old data is rarely known until someone opens it.
- Stakeholder count. The more people who must approve each decision, the longer each decision takes, and waiting time costs money on any contract model.
These four are also the hardest to price at the start, which is why they so often turn a fixed-price project into a series of change requests. If your project has several of them, plan for discovery before you ask for a fixed price.
A five-question test before you sign
Answer each question with yes or no.
- Can you list every screen, report and integration today?
- Is every system you need to connect to documented, with a test environment?
- Do you know how much old data must move, and what state it is in?
- Can one person approve decisions within a few days?
- Will the requirements still be the same in three months?
Four or five yes answers point to fixed price. Two or fewer point to time and materials with a ceiling, or to a paid discovery phase first. A mix suggests splitting the project: fixed price for the parts you can describe, time and materials for the parts you cannot.
Frequently asked questions
Is a fixed-price software project cheaper than time and materials?
Not necessarily. A fixed price includes the vendor's allowance for risk, so a well-run time-and-materials project on clear work can cost less. Fixed price buys certainty about the total, not a lower total.
How do I stop scope creep on a fixed-price project?
Write acceptance criteria for each deliverable, agree a change-request process in the contract, and keep a list of ideas for a later phase instead of adding them mid-build.
Can I start on time and materials and switch to fixed price later?
Yes. Starting with a paid discovery phase and fixing the price for the build once the scope is clear is a common and sensible pattern.
Should AI product design be fixed fee or time and materials?
Usually both, in sequence. AI work carries an unknown that ordinary software does not: whether the model handles your real data well is only clear after testing it on that data. A fixed fee suits a short discovery phase whose deliverable is a tested prototype and a written scope. Once those tests show what the build needs, the build can be fixed-price, or time and materials with a ceiling.
Does Elroot Labs publish its rates?
No. The cost depends on the four drivers above, so we price each project from a written brief. You can send a project brief and we will reply with the engagement model we would suggest and why.
